Ex-Jehovah's Witnesses-Critical Thinkers » Critical Thought Podcast

144

The Critical Thought encourages you to think critically about the teachings of Jehovah's Witnesses. As former members and teachers in this group, we have inside knowledge to help raise public awareness. We understand the psychological tactics the organization uses to attract new members.

Our goal isn't to attack the religion, but to share what we've learned about how the group operates. We want to expose the false teachings they use to control their followers. Many members carry a heavy burden of shame, fear, and guilt, struggling to keep up with the group's expectations. Some want to leave but stay out of fear of losing family and friends, pretending to be committed when they're not.

Through our platform, we hope to help anyone feeling trapped by the group's impossible standards or prevent others from joining. We aim to support educators, mend broken family relationships, and motivate people to pursue their education. If we can help even one person, we consider that a success.

Recent Episodes
  • Why Do Jehovah's Witnesses Reject Jesus as Their Mediator
    Apr 18, 2025 – 10:33
  • Did You Notice a Different Vibe at the 2025 Jehovah's Witness Memorial
    Apr 18, 2025 – 10:08
  • No More Seats in Heaven - Reserved for Jehovah's Witnesses Only
    Apr 18, 2025 – 14:06
  • Top Seven Things You Should Know About the Jehovah's Witnesses Memorial
    Apr 18, 2025 – 08:05
  • Jehovah's Witnesses: Special Talk Can Truth Be Found
    Apr 18, 2025 – 07:46
  • Watchtower's Lies, Loopholes & Legal Strategies
    Apr 18, 2025 – 14:31
  • Jehovah's Witnesses and the Paranoia Trap
    Apr 18, 2025 – 08:39
  • How to Avoid Crucial Mistakes When Leaving Jehovah's Witnesses
    Feb 25, 2025 – 10:57
  • Jehovah's Witnesses: Fear and the Mechanism of Control
    Feb 25, 2025 – 18:20
  • Jehovah's Witnesses: Are Their Failed Teachings the Closest Thing to the Truth?
    Feb 25, 2025 – 09:47
  • The Governing Body of Jehovah's Witnesses Truth or Tainted?
    Jan 30, 2025 – 21:39
  • Life at Bethel: Good, Bad & Ugly Annual Meeting 2024
    Oct 5, 2024 – 15:42
  • Monica Velin Rodriguez - Mother Abducted by her Jehovah's Witness Family
    Sep 5, 2024 – 51:38
  • Freedom of Speech: Voices Rise Against the Governing Body of Jehovah's Witnesses
    Apr 20, 2024 – 01:29:57
  • Awaken Truths - Jeven & Lexie Jehovah's Witness Exit Story
    Apr 11, 2024 – 01:07:55
  • Governing Body's Policy Changes: Unpacking the Aftermath
    Mar 23, 2024 – 15:11
  • Recovery From Our Accident - Navigating Healthcare as Ex-JWs
    Feb 12, 2024 – 18:13
  • Interview with Efrain: Why I Left the Jehovah's Witness Faith
    Nov 13, 2023 – 01:11:26
  • Jehovah's Witnesses: No More Counting Field Service Hours & Placements
    Oct 8, 2023 – 01:26:14
  • Jehovah's Witnesses, We Have a Deficit - Where's My Money?
    Oct 4, 2023 – 15:27
  • Why Former Bethelite Elder Leaves the Jehovah's Witness Faith
    Oct 4, 2023 – 24:45
  • EXJW Support Group: Empowering Lives After Leaving the Jehovah's Witnesses
    Sep 20, 2023 – 34:35
  • From Faith to Freedom: Meet Phylice, She's Totally Awake
    Sep 13, 2023 – 42:48
  • Meet Daria! Your Best Free Therapy Session After Leaving the Jehovah's Witnesses
    Aug 25, 2023 – 01:28:51
  • Jehovah's Witness Elder Facing Mortality: Regrets After 40 Years of Shunning His Daughter
    Aug 7, 2023 – 42:33
  • Jehovah's Witnesses - How Much Do You Care About Children? Hear Lucille's Account of Reporting Child CSA
    Jul 31, 2023 – 22:19
  • Jehovah's Witnesses: The Special Treatment of Anthony Morris!
    Jul 31, 2023 – 10:45
  • New Charges Unveiled: Five Additional Jehovah's Witnesses Indicted for CSA in Pennsylvania
    Jul 14, 2023 – 11:46
  • Why Jehovah's Witnesses Don't Celebrate Mother's Day
    May 14, 2023 – 06:50
  • Struggles of Jehovah's Witness Youths - Should I Regular Pioneer After High School
    May 7, 2023 – 16:57
  • Navigating the Watchtower Judicial Process: Six Reporting Guidelines for Elders
    Apr 29, 2023 – 17:54
  • The Memorial: Governing Body vs. Faithful & Discreet Slave
    Apr 12, 2023 – 15:22
  • Life at Bethel - Jehovah's Witness Voting Members
    Apr 5, 2023 – 31:53
  • Eva's Story - My Family Survived the Holocaust
    Apr 3, 2023 – 40:16
  • Meet June & Jared and Learn how their family faded from the Jehovah's Witness Faith
    Mar 10, 2023 – 43:17
  • Livestream: Governing Body Member of Jehovah's Witnesses, Anthony Morris, Removed from Position
    Mar 2, 2023 – 01:11:12
  • Zoom Meetings Cancelled - If You Love Jehovah, You Will Go Back to In Person Meetings
    Jan 29, 2023 – 11:30
  • Serena Williams: Gets Baptized as one of Jehovah's Witnesses
    Jan 12, 2023 – 11:39
  • Murder Suicide in Thornton, CO - Jehovah's Witnesses & the Tragic Outcome of Shunning
    Jan 2, 2023 – 18:06
  • Jehovah's Witnesses & Career Choices
    Nov 22, 2022 – 09:19
  • Why I Left Jehovah's Witnesses 43 Years Ago, but Went Back During COVID
    Nov 14, 2022 – 01:06:27
  • How Does the Jehovah's Witness Culture Impact Your Mental Health?
    Oct 10, 2022 – 46:03
  • Mental Health Challenges of Jehovah's Witnesses
    Sep 12, 2022 – 23:11
  • What Else Did They Lie About? Interview with Shayla Hudson Riggle
    Aug 31, 2022 – 01:09:47
  • The Top Six Questions You Should Ask a Jehovah's Witness
    Aug 31, 2022 – 16:25
  • Jehovah's Witnesses: Don't Accept that Scholarship!
    Jul 29, 2022 – 16:38
  • The Power of the Platform...How What We Say Can Affect People in Our Audience.
    Jul 16, 2022 – 12:06
  • Jehovah's Witnesses, Secretly Accepting Blood Transfusions
    Jul 5, 2022 – 30:58
  • Does the Governing Body of Jehovah's Witnesses Represent the Modern Day Pharisees?
    Jun 28, 2022 – 23:28
  • Bethel Leak - Unhappy Members (Physically In, Mentally Out) - Headquarters of Jehovah's Witnesses
    Jun 13, 2022 – 13:49
Recent Reviews
  • Carolyn617
    Horrible
    Sorry these things happened. Please keep praying
  • ACB0690
    Recent Pomo
    Thank you for your show. I have recently left the JW. I was at bethel Warwick. I left at 34. And I am the only one from my family that left. I divorced my mentally abusive husband and really seen first hand the second class woman process. The brothers were not there to help me but to help my ex to keep his reputation. Your show has been a wonderful help to me. Thank you.
  • Nobelhus
    On Point, On Topic, and Accurate
    It is very important that before joining any organization, you do your research. Many people that find themselves beginning a study with the JWs have suffered somehow or at some point in their lives that leaves them asking questions. Questions that we as humans have been asking for thousands of years. In modern history hundreds of religions have cropped up claiming to have exclusive access to what is called “the truth,” however when you really look in to the teachings and history of the Watchtower, you will find it is more similar to all modern day religion than what they tell you. From the hierarchy, to the rules, dogmas, and teachings to Ex-Communicating, yes, they will kick you out if you oppose any of their teachings that at one time you said you would not disagree with. Just like a company kicks you out for opposing the leadership or the direction it is taking. Oh yes, JT and Lady Cee are on Point, On Topic and Accurate in the information they are giving you. Like JT says, “The watchtower has a good product.” Probably one of the best in the religious market, and also as JT says, “I would rather have questions I can’t answer than answers I can’t question.” Be grateful that this source of info is available. Each episode is thoughtfully laid out without rambling or run-on rants. Interviewees are allowed to tell their story and it doesn’t hurt that sometimes opinions may crop up but I would put the percentage of what is discussed at about 99.8% accurate. Thank you JT&Lady Cee. Watch you guys all the time.
  • Wiley2772
    Critical Thinking is NOT encouraged
    Any group that tells you NOT to look to outside sources for ideas or research on any subject, or who tells you not to seek secondary or higher education, is manipulating you into staying malleable for further brain washing. The next suggestion the JW’s have for you, instead of going to college, is to just work a part-time job and spend the rest of your time making more JW disciples and getting people to convert to their doctrine. Members are striped of their autonomy and not allowed critical thinking or personal choice. They are programmed to obey and report back on other JWs. It keeps you in a constant state of fear from even being yourself around people. You develop “imposter syndrome” and lead a double life because you have to in order to survive. I know this because I was born into the JW cult. At age 5, I knew I wanted out. I also knew I had 13 more years to have to hide my true thoughts and feelings from my family that I was not a believer because they had already dumped off my oldest sister out of the house when she was 16 and I was 2. They claimed my sister worshiped Satan and was a lesbian which was enough for my delusional mother to send my oldest sister out of our home. The reality was my sister was smoking cigarettes and wanting to go out with her friends from school instead of the approved JWs. I spent my entire childhood knowing all my friends and family would be torn away and shun me when i finally broke from their cult at 18. It was extremely traumatic and it still affects me now at 50 years old. Thanks for letting me know there are others who have survived escaping this dangerous group. They need to be exposed.
  • Tootyred
    Thank you- bless you
    I’m a third generation JW, and left when I was 19 after living in foster care because of the abuse of my Elder Father. I knew I made the right decision when I had my son. And I knew that I couldn’t subject my child to the abuses of my own childhood. Thank you!!!
  • mmares12
    Love it
    Great Podcast. I can relate to just about every single topic. This show is the realest. JT sounds just like the elders which makes it so much easier on the ears when he critiques the cult. Haha, if that doesn’t make me brainwashed!!!
  • mmw19796
    Excellent!
    Love This podcast! Shines such a great light. I find it extremely accurate. Makes me feel not so alone!
  • nattyg1978lovespodcasts
    Cult Girls gives this podcaster 5 stars!
    Excellent content! I’m the author of the new release graphic novel CULT GIRLS (on Amazon & Barnes) by Natalie Grand. It’s a light hearted comedy, based on a true story of 4 women born, raised in the Jehovah’s Witness cult. If you are looking for an anti-cult activist special guest my Twitter is Natalie Grand.
  • Kellybelly0801
    Great podcast!
    Thank you for helping people wake up! I’m so grateful to have found your podcast.
  • dfknvvthijfseunvxsuj
    Disfellowed
    In the 1970s, my mom was just followed because she allowed me to join the Cub Scouts. She thought it would be OK if I join the Cub Scouts just as long as I didn’t wear a flag on my uniform or saluted the flag. I just wanted to do it because I wanted to be with my friends and have fun.
  • bdjdgh
    Pretty stupid
    Helpful? Informative? Yeah no, you all are sick from the head thinking bashing on a religion is okay. And if your significant other is trying to teach their kids and you don't agree, go cry about it😃. Or you know what, get divorced, just let them be🙄
  • Trotti_Texas
    Disfellowshipping
    My ex husband was disfellowshipped as a young adult. He’s now 42 and has yet to have a relationship with his parents. It’s extremely sad because he’s an only child and his children are the only grandchildren. The parents were originally allowed to speak to him if it involved “family matters” but that faded over time.
  • Tiana144
    Great listen from a childhood witness
    It’s a shame that I thought this was how we were supposed to live our lives! Thank you for thinking critically. This prompted me to do an episode on my own podcast, so thank you for inspiring also! ❤️
  • Tony Toledo
    Awesome
    Loving this breakdown of the nonsense I grew up with
  • DHSHBH
    Solution
    I’m not a Jehová witness, but I have meet many Jehová witnesses. I also study with them time to time and have asked difficult questions to the witness and based on the Bible theirs always a answer. This gentleman that says that he was in the organization has probably been impeached for improper behavior or bad decisions. Listen to the podcast and see how he carries the conversation with resentment and hate towards the organization, but fails to give you a better path!
  • The resistance is real
    I still believe in God though...
    I hadn’t voluntarily disassociated myself from the Witnesses but it just happened. I’ve been disowned basically by my parents. Since childhood I always felt something was wrong with the organization. Going door to door I felt we were encroaching on people’s quiet time and sleep. I don’t hold anything against the witnesses. Many of them if not a majority are really good people, just a little misguided. Thank you Lady C and JT for your wonderful podcast helping us to see the forest from the trees. It’s encouraging to know that because we turned away from this otherwise “toxic” organization, we have not turned away from God, we aren’t the only ones who feel this way. We should still pray for our fellow man.
  • Arthur-Vandelay
    Thank you
    I left 20 years ago after raised a witness. After leaving _everything_ behind for a new life I appreciate the encouraging words from so many years of mental anguish and spiritual and emotional torture. My family may have been destroyed but at least I have a future outside the oppressive way of life. Thank you for giving me the strength knowing others have had similar issues.
  • Nodnarb79
    Thank you
    I love you guys! I am so thankful for the work you’ve done and are doing! I am married to a woman who was raised as a Jehovah’s Witness. It wasn’t a big deal before kids but now it’s my biggest battle , to keep the watch towers claws away from my kids.
  • keyged18
    Really enjoy this podcast!
    For years I thought I was crazy for thinking these very things that are discussed. Very eye opening and informative. Please listen.
  • Cougar310
    Great podcast to "awake" sheeple
    It amazes me to see how people can fall for anything Jehovah,s witnesses tell you in their so called "book" study. Extra ordinary claims require extra ordinary evidence which they dont have. I guess the "FOG" spread from the platform at any KH permeates weak minded individuals and really does take away their thinking capacity to see they are being hoodwinked by this Corporation . Keep up the good work !
  • Dock@7426
    Trash
    LoL it’s crazy how ppl push things they can’t explain. I no longer go to the hall but I’d never talk bad or disrespect the witnesses. Your hiding behind “lady c “ and “jt”. If you felt so strong about your new belief then stop hiding.
  • Evan Ann Hurt
    Very informative and accurate
    Enjoyed your podcasts. Keep them coming
  • Puncheonrum
    Would have been 5 stars but..
    The entire series suddenly is ALL about women. You are alienating almost half of your listeners with the constant brother bashing. That's not critical thinking as were the earlier episodes. Keep in mind that this is a four star rating so it has to be excellent for starters. Hope you get back to the stuff that affects us all in general.
  • pinkhoody
    Like talking to a friend over coffee
    "JT" handles the bulk of this podcast. He was raised as a Jehovah's Witness, pioneered, went to Bethel, and became an elder. If you're already reading this review, and you have doubts, you might as well listen (I mean, if you're reading this, you're already curious. There's a reason for that). What you'll hear are people giving their very down-to-earth experiences with this religion. Chances are you will learn things you never knew about Jehovah's Witnesses (yes, even if you're already one, yourself). I love this podcast for its information. I'm a "lifer" and I've learned new things just from this show that I never knew- I've already been out for almost 10 years and somehow never have stumbled onto some of this information- even with all the research I've done. One of my favorite things about this podcast are the too-true moments that I found myself giving a knowing smile or chuckle at- things to which only a JW or ex-JW could relate. :) Thank you for this excellent and informative show. Keep it up!
  • Controlsguy
    Smart guy
    This is great stuff even if your not a jw or ex jw
  • Kno on
    Consider this
    Very good information. Have you ever considered how much influence the free masonry has had on teachings/culture. For instance, Russell linked Egypt to Shem(really?), and the high priests in Egypt wore no facial hair. Perhaps that's why the Caucasian brothers in the Service Dept could not wear mustaches. I'm just saying. Why is it that the Bible characters are so pale when there is evidence that the earliest humans had dark skin? I asked a fair skinned sister and she angrily asked "what color do you think they are supposed to be?" Hmmmmm....
  • cymtech
    Awesome Podcast - Critical Thought
    Very informative show! Love it and the brevity. It gets to the point and really makes you think. Keep it coming y’all.
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork on this page are property of the podcast owner, and not endorsed by UP.audio.