The interviewer needs to bring some clarity to her questions. She really fumbles over herself.

I really enjoy this pod cast because Emily is a very intelligent and highly articulate woman. Im always captivated and intrigued with the way she tells the stories. Love it! 👍

Fascinating guests. Really enjoying. Emily really gets to the bottom of the facts. Huge fan!

Emily’s thoughtful questions are always wrapped in compassion and empathy. She is able to quietly listen while the guest responds without jumping in to follow up before they finish talking. At the end, Emily give her guests a heartfelt thank you and commends them for being brave, tenacious or having persevered in finding the truth. We should all have an Emily in our lives.

As long as you don’t say “At the end of the day.” Annoying any over used. Other then then that, it’s ok.

The cases I’ve listened to have been very well explained. Some I’ve never heard of. Emily is a great interviewer. She’s so empathetic. Her legal experience also helps.

Emily Compagno did an especially spectacular job on this MMIP case from Nome Alaska. The podcast ran long only because she highlighted Flo’s family; her mom and her sister as well as a local & state-wide activist leader. The end of the show emphasizes that love is at the core of this activism. As my sisters disappear and are murdered, I was moved to tear and love to DO something. Emily asks her guests to give us a path to action! Bills in the state legislature! Marches! Raising families’ voices. (Share this podcast! And there are others!) thank You Emily! Good job. 👍👏🏾🫶👏👏🏿❤️👏🏻👏🏼🤟🤟

Mid

Listened to the Golden State Killer and couldn’t finish the episode! One of the ladies has such a could mouth! Too many F bombs! So unnecessary!

Almost all these cases are overdone The vocals had me just stop listening. Made for an unpleasant experience. Emily is great but she is so close to the microphone that when you listen on headphones or earphones it is beyond frustrating. The recording of Dr Baden was terrible too

There are lots of crime podcasts out there. But the interview format with Emily’s insightful, dizzyingly articulate questions makes this one my favorite. Every time I see Emily here, on Gutfeld, or wherever I am always wrestling with whether it’s her intelligence, her grace and charm, or her beauty that is most captivating. She is the feminine ideal.

Always interesting, she is a great interviewer

Thank you. Nice.

Excellent job interviewing the guests to obtain a recap of the crime but done with care and compassion for the victims and their families.

Emily thoughtfully walks us through each case with her usual inquisitiveness. adding grace and empathy throughout. She’s a natural. Very gifted and talented. Great stories and interviews.

I like how Emily interviews her guests, doesn’t interrupt every 5 seconds . Unlike other podcast where the host never lets the guest finish a sentence.

Emily is a thoughtful interviewer with the right tone for an insightful program. She asked the questions I wanted to ask.

As much as it pains me to say anything nice about Fox, this show is amazing. I’m a former attorney myself, and I listen to A LOT of true crime podcasts…this one is probably the best I’ve heard. Emily is a great host, the guests are beyond interesting, and the whole thing is well produced. More content please!!

Just found Emily’s podcast today. I absolutely love it. She has such a soothing voice and is so genuine. I love true crime and this has just became one of my favorites ♥️

Emily asks good questions of each person she interviews and shows real heart and compassion in difficult moments. I look forward to more human interest reporting. These are not stories being told, they are a retelling by real people, some of whom have lived through unspeakable situations.

Excellent interviews, great questions, thorough explanations & descriptions. This is a great podcast!

This is SUCH a great Podcast! The Host asks such great

I paid for the no advertising option for the year. It’s a lie!!! They play ads on every single podcast every single episode even with the subscription. Need to get a refund. Most have regular ads. Some only have fox podcast advertising. Which are still ads I am paying to NOT HEAR!!

This is so comprehensive so compassionate and I can’t stop listening. Her compassion and incisive story telling is the best!

Fantastic show!!! Emily needs a primetime show on Fox!!! Let’s go!!!!!

Great show!!

If you enjoy a good real life crime story this is legit worth checking out

Good flow, easy to listen to

The biggest crime of all was when Miss Emily stole my heart… Great podcast baby!

When I begin listening to an episode, I am immediately mesmerized and captivated! The stories are unbelievable and clearly researched and articulated. Keep up the great work! ~Jill~

The best show so far! And I love them all!!!

Emily asks great questions and doesn’t get in the way of the story. Really entertaining and informative.

Great presentation of the case . Refreshing look at true crimes. Emily’s skill at interviewing is evident! This has become my favorite podcast.

Emily is so easy to listen to and carries a great conversation.

Really appreciate Emily’s interview style…she’s articulate, empathetic, and allows her guests to answer questions and share stories without interruption. She’s a great listener and a great interviewer who has the ability to put guests at ease. You get a sense that she truly cares about the impact these horrible events have had on all those involved. And because she truly does care, her guests are often surprised to find that they’re being fully open & honest w/ her.

In resubmitting this review I must point out a couple things that I think need to be addressed. I noticed that Emily has a tendency to give high praise to the federal elements of law enforcement that she interviews and showcases. My problem with that is the federal agencies are also very fallible in regards to case management and the offering of resources. I have been given the brush off personally during serious crimes when trying to enlist federal assistance and have been denied their involvement. At one point even having go in front of and plead with an AUSA to follow through with a federal prosecution of two violent drug gangs after being attached to a task force. Another aspect of the show that bothers me is in some episodes she has guests on that bash the local police departments. In the last episode the guest said outright that the New Orleans Police Department is “not that good”. There are tons and tons of cases out there that the NOPD has worked on that have come to successful conclusions. But also let me explain something, police DO NOT investigate most adult missing persons unless clear blatant evidence of a crime is observed and recovered. A lot of people DO NOT WANT TO BE FOUND. This show smears these local and state departments while deifying the feds all too often for me to continue listening. I hope someone reads this and understands that I have the utmost respect for Emily as a journalist and personality but I cannot sit by and let her host episodes attacking local departments out of ignorance. Pick some cases that are interesting and stop kissing the feds butts. Its demeaning especially when you actually know them. I also have heard very negative things about Jay Dobyns to listen to Emily fawn over him like he is, to use his term, a “supercop” kind of made me laugh. Showcase actual “cops” and quit with the feds. Also, what is with the missing persons cases? Is this an attempt to get a case opened to get the podcast traction? Cause that is exploitative and lame. I like the idea of this type of podcast but not in its current form.

Emily is a true pro and if you’re a fan of True Crime, look no further than this podcast.

Excellent so far, letting the story come out, with just a little guiding by Emily, is an extremely great style to listen to and understand.

Doesn’t know how to lead an interview. Supposed to be about children and within 6 Minutes said lets turn now to adults. Just poor interviewer.

Emily’s voice is so pleasant and she is incredibly smart and informative! Great podcast!

Emily is so super addicting. Her energy is Off the charts!!

Not bad at all. 5 stars

Just listened to the Polly Klass episode. Insightful interview. Emily is so bright and easy to listen to. Also…whether you (Emily) would have wanted that spot on The Five or not, if the public could have voted, you would have been my #1 pick. I was so happy when I saw you were starting a podcast. Thank you!

Just listened for first time, fantastic podcast!!

Emily, thank you for your new excellent podcast. Your excellence in interviewing very sensitive cases with compassion and expertise is truly to be commended.

Well researched and engaging.

Love Emily on Fox Outnumbered, so I couldn’t wait to listen to her podcast. Just listened to one episode so far….but it did not disappoint!

Being a true crime super consumer I can honestly say this is a refreshing format where we get the story from those closest to the event. Layer on Emily’s legal expertise and her amazing questions, and we are off to the races. One can tell a lot of research was done in advance yet Emily and the guest are in the moment. I love it! More please 😊

I love listening to true crime on other podcasts and YT. Great idea and Emily was the perfect choice to host it. Just wish she spoke a bit more. Would love to hear more of her opinions and takes on the events that unfolded.

I enjoyed it very much but felt perhaps the response should be edited a bit. I felt Maras sister did not answer questions directly and talked in circles a bit. I'm excited to listen to others!