Recent Episodes
-
116. The Doctor Who Vanished The Day Before 9/11
Apr 23, 2025 – 38:27 -
115. The Cursed Painting - The Hands Resist Him
Apr 16, 2025 – 38:05 -
114. The Bloody Custody Battle - The Murder of Angila Wilder
Apr 9, 2025 – 39:27 -
113. The Disappearance of Joan Risch
Apr 2, 2025 – 43:52 -
112. The Chameleon Killer
Mar 26, 2025 – 41:04 -
Presenting: KILLER MINDS
Mar 24, 2025 – 10:25 -
111. The Man In The Ceiling
Mar 19, 2025 – 38:41 -
110. The Spa Day Murder - Sabina Rosas
Mar 12, 2025 – 40:14 -
109. The Lady of The Dunes: The Solved Cold Case
Mar 5, 2025 – 38:41 -
108. The Stoplight Assassin
Feb 26, 2025 – 37:01 -
107. The Alderney UFO Incident
Feb 19, 2025 – 39:49 -
106. The Axe Murder Mystery
Feb 12, 2025 – 39:53 -
105. The Missing News Anchor
Feb 5, 2025 – 41:42 -
104. Who Killed Robert Wone?
Jan 29, 2025 – 39:47 -
103. The Bizarre Disappearance of "Madman" Mike: The Backyard Time Traveler
Jan 22, 2025 – 34:09 -
102. The Bigfoot Homicide
Jan 15, 2025 – 35:09 -
101. The Tragic Olympian Murder
Jan 8, 2025 – 36:40 -
100. The Flannan Isle Mystery
Dec 18, 2024 – 40:47 -
99. The Teenage Monsters
Dec 11, 2024 – 35:25 -
98. The Circleville Letters
Dec 4, 2024 – 41:49 -
97. The Murder of Ally Kostial
Nov 20, 2024 – 42:23 -
96. The Victims of Pam Hupp
Nov 13, 2024 – 45:25 -
95. The Fatal Exorcism - The Murder of Scott Callahan
Nov 6, 2024 – 36:04 -
94. The Abductions of Franklin Delano Floyd
Oct 30, 2024 – 38:15 -
93. The House of Death
Oct 23, 2024 – 40:30 -
92. The Goth Girl Murder
Oct 16, 2024 – 43:37 -
91. Fort Benning Incident
Oct 9, 2024 – 35:08 -
90. The Ignored Murders of Chicago
Oct 2, 2024 – 37:07 -
89. Cicada 3301 - The Internet’s Greatest Mystery
Sep 25, 2024 – 37:38 -
88. The Angel of Death
Sep 18, 2024 – 39:29 -
87. Mysteries in the Sky
Sep 11, 2024 – 45:43 -
86. The Real Life Michael Myers
Sep 4, 2024 – 41:20 -
85. Snake or Sinister Scheme? The Ben Renick Case
Aug 28, 2024 – 38:43 -
84. The Stonehenge Mysteries
Aug 21, 2024 – 38:12 -
83. The Chemical Lab Coverup
Aug 14, 2024 – 42:54 -
82. The Unsolved Mystery of Tara Calico
Aug 7, 2024 – 32:24 -
81. The Peace Corps Tragedy
Jul 31, 2024 – 34:46 -
80. The 4th World Murder Teens - Anne Perry
Jul 24, 2024 – 40:15 -
79. The Secrets Behind The Denver International Airport
Jul 17, 2024 – 48:15 -
78. The Mysterious Dyatlov Pass Incident
Jul 10, 2024 – 38:10 -
77. The Cliffside Hate Crime - Scott Johnson
Jul 3, 2024 – 35:10 -
76. The Legend of The Mothman
Jun 26, 2024 – 29:12 -
75. The Prime Minister Who Vanished - Harold Holt
Jun 19, 2024 – 31:11 -
74. The Canadian UFO Incident
Jun 12, 2024 – 33:48 -
73. The “Cereal” Poisoner
Jun 5, 2024 – 33:36 -
72. Uncovering The Shocking Truth Behind The Vampire
May 29, 2024 – 27:51 -
71. What Happened to Mica Miller?
May 22, 2024 – 35:38 -
70. Tin Foil Tales: The Death of Princes Diana
May 15, 2024 – 34:44 -
69. The Teenagers Who Seduced and Killed Nazis
May 8, 2024 – 34:45 -
Larry Web Confesses On His Deathbed To Cold Case Murder Of Two Girls
May 4, 2024 – 12:10
Recent Reviews
-
Mass podcast fiendEpisode 115One of the best episodes of any podcasts ever! Long time listener, excellent, wish it was longer!!!!
-
Jaimie with 2 👀💕I absolutely LOVE this 😊
-
Nashalie😎Literally could not live without itCould not go through a Wednesday w out binged
-
MollieDayLove this true crime.Into the Dark
-
Into the dark 911Top 3 best true crime shows of all time on any podcast platformShe is the best her voice is so calming 🌮🫔🌮🫔🌮
-
xoninaaaaHi Payton!I LOVE THE SHOW!!! 😁🥰🩷👏🏼 you’re so funny and I love your voice! The way you tell things is so lovely. Look forward to all your podcast well MWMH and this one lol you have a friend here! Love youuuuu 🫂💗🥹✨
-
kshea325Always supporting!Love Payton’s story telling. This is great & so is MWMH! They seem like great people & a couple I love to support.. especially when their content is excellent!
-
Autumn BrymerI. Love. Peyton!!I love this show and how open she is in her episodes. The Oh No Media Platforms reminds me of Mr Ballen who I have also listened to since the beginning. Both of these platforms are my absolute favorite and I look forward to these episodes coming out every week!
-
blessedismandyInsightfulPayton is great hosting by herself and with her husband!! This podcast gives us another dose of crime that I didn’t know I needed!!
-
KirstenmariaI love oh no mediaThis show is the best with phenomenal research and they way Peyton presents the story’s to us I love thank you so much 🫶🏼 been a longtime listener and viewer from mwmh to rise in crime
-
XchubbykittyXAmazingI came from MWMH and I love both podcasts. As of right now, they’re the only podcasts I listen to
-
NikkijuneLove the shows!Hi! I’m a fairly new listener and subscriber and I LOVE all your shows! I would love to hear you explore and discuss more paranormal stuff on Into the Dark. Keep up the awesome work!
-
cindellouSay My Name Say My NameOnly listened to one episode - it was about Teteke and she said that name so many times I wanted to scream!!! The content is good, the story is interesting but the presentation is unbearable.
-
simsaljarYou need ad transitions!To go from listening about a man going missing, straight into “hello there, this is your vagina calling!” Is really insensitive, girl do better.
-
Ivett12Love it!Love your show, i just started to listen to it, because i always hear about it in the Murder With my husband show:) Sometimes i get anxiety because i am grieving.. but i noticed the morning cold plunge really helps especially if you get it more often try to get a cold plunge it really works ❤️❤️
-
ShaSha827VarietyLove your solo show! But what I really came here to say is “please please please! Teach your mother how to pronounce words properly!”
-
soccergurl11The true crime pod you’re looking for!I love this podcast. I’ve been listening for a while now, and it remains true to itself. Payton does a great job at sticking to the story and does not go off on opinionated tangents that distract from the story. The stories are interesting, and told in a caring way. Would 10/10 recommend giving this a listen!!
-
Artist2256Addicting!Once you enter into the dark… you never want to leave! Oh No Media is LITERALLY THE ONLY TRUE CRIME I LISTEN TO. I appreciate all of the different type of cases she covers and keeping you on your toes. I also really enjoy that she shows so much respect to the victims and their loved ones.
-
Nalley06You are AMAZING!I have followed MMH and it was a no brainer to listen here when you did your own thing! I love supporting women in all roles and I support you💕 I heard the episode today where you shared you have been struggling with MH so wanted to give some love and post here what a great show INTO THE DARK is. My hubs and I are putting 4 kids through private school and travel sports, thus I don’t do Patreon for any podcast because, living is expensive. I work in sales so connecting is is how I pay it forward when convo comes up “What are your fav podcasts?”, YOU (both) are awesome:) Keep it up! Bunch of weirdos out here that look forward to the work you (both) do and you are appreciated. You are real, unapologetically. It’s refreshing and while I have a decade on you, you both truly inspire me as a wife through your genuine companionship to build each other up. That’s what it is about. Xo
-
Sacha NikkaylaPodcast Queen2025, March 11th - I listen to a lot of podcasts and I love the way you podcast all around , your voice sounds peaceful to me and for my nerves ha ha it’s soothing, Even if murder content , so that says a lot ! I have not been listening for years and years. I did find your podcast in 2024 but I’m so excited to listen more to the podcasts that I haven’t heard yet, and that you guys put out I’m excited to learn more about how I read that you support Mental Health challenges and what’s behind that. Have a blessed day.
-
woohooitsjennaLove itHer story telling is so special and you can tell so much care goes into each episode !! Only thing I look forward to on Wednesdays
-
Hihihihihihihihihirock1234yaBest podcast!I wish there was an episode every night this is apart of my nightly self care routine! Love this podcast so so much thank you for everything you do Payton your talent, your realness, and your advocacy for mental health awareness 💜
-
Kaylaaa414Favorite but going downhillI love Murder with my Husband which is what made me interested in Into the Dark. The stories she told when she first started the show were great. I loved the themed cases she would do like the Waffle House and IHOP murders and the Kids Killing Kids ones. But it seems like now she just does random cases that are boring and very short, almost as if it’s thrown together just to say she has done an episode. I hope her passion comes back and she starts to do interesting cases that actually are intriguing and fun to listen to.
-
acaro21...Love!!!I’ve only been a listener for a couple weeks but I love her coverage of crimes I’m already aware of and she I’ve never heard of. Also thanks for the tv show recommendation of Landman. I am often on the lookout for new shows to try and I’m going to give that a try!
-
Sam_Adams09Love!I stumbled onto this podcast one day randomly and loved it so much from day one. My son had told me about MWMH after I told him I was listening to this and even though I am obsessed with that podcast I love that this one talks about all things spooky and “tin foil”. Some of my faves are definitely the UFO episodes. Much love!
-
MorbidOutdoorsPodcastgreat episodesI love this podcast. I first heard of you through MWMH but I also the solo show just as much!
-
Yamileth C.LoveHave been listening since it was first name Binged. Took me 107 episodes in to write a review (mostly due to listening to on the drive home) but finally doing it. Love the podcast !
-
aavamillrBest Podcast10/10
-
Haleyharlan58GoodI like some episodes but they are all put together great.
-
BriOnlyZhePayton is best true crime podcaster!I started listening to Into the Dark after seeing a billboard for it a few years back before the name change (binged). I really appreciate Payton's respect for people from all walks of life and opinions, her mindfulness of victims and their loved ones, her trigger warnings and generally family friendly vibe. I've listened to every episode of both of her podcasts and relistened to several of my favorites, sharing them with friends and family on occasion. She's my very favorite podcaster, particularly in this genre, and I look forward to her podcasts every week.
-
1$346Listen and we don’t judgeI gave the show a 5 star review, this is one of the first podcasts I have ever listened to, I started while driving across these lovely United States from Virginia to cali that was 2 years ago. I never thought about actually interacting, I just didn’t think it would be acknowledged. I just want to say thank you, this show has entertained me through some really tough times which I know is weird but I enjoy the stories and how they are presented, thank you.
-
nelehwI gave 5 stars because you are great PaytonHowever I do e joy MWMH more as i’m not into tin foil tales etc but i love you girl
-
jren.Into the dark.Love your podcast.
-
BailsParkerKillin’ it! No pun intendedAlgorithm Bump Edit Peyton, you’re such an incredible storyteller! How could I give you anything less than 5 stars?! You’re killin’ it
-
Marianna94!Makes long drives shorter ❤️I absolutely love love love this show. I listen to this show as I drive and it makes my long drives shorter and traffic much more bearable.
-
TIFFMitchell22PEYTON IS THE BESTPeyton and MWMH are literally the only podcast I will listen to. They are both amazing and I love them so much!
-
kaglass3AwesomeI wish I got on board sooner
-
Rachel817Love itThis is the only podcast I anxiously wait for new episodes to be posted. Your topics are always interesting and I enjoy the style of storytelling.
-
Frosty JoanneGREAT PODCASTI love this Podcast. Murder with my husband (MWMH) is great too. Great job Payton!!! The only thing I would change is to make the episodes a little longer. 😀
-
LeightonnnnMy fav! 🤍🤍🤍🤍OHNO media podcasts are my favorite podcasts!!
-
saikobbget it peyton! 💖💞💅🏻Peyton i LOVE your podcasts!! please make them longer 🙏
-
MAAAADSUSLove itI love this podcast & MWMH. People are always finding something to complain about. Start your own podcast & try doing it without ads... Lol, the ads let them cont. Making episodes. I love Payton. Also, what is with people complaining about her mood? She is HUMAN & even when “down” she is STILL SHOWING UP! Someone complained about technical errors where their episodes would erase or not record... How exactly is that their fault? Ppl are more worried about finding something to complain about instead of enjoying stuff & since they are the experts maybe they should start their own podcasts 🤷🏻♀️ everyone has a right to an opinion but some of these are just heartless & silly. Great podcast, she cares about the victims.
-
trp2014Best True Crime podcastThis is my favorite True Crime podcast by far, along with Murder with My Husband! I have listened to many throughout the years and Payton does the best job with the details and story telling that supports the victims story. My husband even started listening with me! Thank you Payton!
-
Cardinal Fred 76Love this show and murder with my husband!!This is 1 of my top 2 podcast to listen to! I drive 1 hour each way to work and this show and MWMH gets me through the commute!!
-
jamieanddFavorite show!Always so fun to listen to. She is a great storyteller!
-
RubaMizAmazingLove listing to Payton. Best story teller on gen planet !
-
TarynloveThanksKeep up good work
-
lwilliamson15172025 is the year of thriving!Thank you!
-
brooketayyFAV PODCASTPayton is the only reason I look forward to Mondays and Wednesdays 🥰
-
RealGiant85Oh no media is the bestI started listening to mwmh. Loved the format and when Payton expanded I followed along. I now listen to all three Oh No Media shows. Thanks for keeping me company in my work day
Similar Podcasts

Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast

Mile Higher

Morbid

Crime Salad

The Murder Diaries

Big Mad True Crime

Lights Out

Murder With My Husband

Serialously with Annie Elise

Murder, Mystery & Makeup

True Crime with Kendall Rae

Heart Starts Pounding: Horrors, Hauntings and Mysteries

Behind You

The Criminal Makeup

Rise N' Crime
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork on this page are property of the podcast owner, and not endorsed by UP.audio.