Started listening to this earlier this year and have been really enjoying it as someone who is also terminally online. I find recaps of internet culture that I hadn’t heard about really interesting but still like hearing what Isabel and Amanda have to say about things I’m already familiar with. Keep up the great work!

I was excited when this podcast was recommended to me because I am extremely online and love thoughtful discussion of the internet and culture, and a cohost with a law degree seemed especially promising for bringing a new perspective. I started with the Bad Art Friend episode as a litmus test since that’s a story I am quite familiar with, especially as a disabled person who witnessed and experienced the vicious ableist attacks and harassment that particular discourse inspired. Unfortunately, the episode was strikingly shallow and almost offensive in its flippancy. The interaction and intersection between disability, race, and class are essential to what I would consider a decent recap of this event, but the hosts only talk about race and didn’t discuss the other two at all. While they talk about race in the summary of the story and in personal context, they erase the real world harassment against disabled people, including non-white disabled people, that the week+ of discourse about this topic created. “Why did this go viral?” they ask repeatedly, and conclude it made people feel good, ignoring that it stayed viral multiple days because the discourse shifted towards ableist harassment!!! Any summary of an event that leaves out the significant harassment it sparks is incomplete and perhaps even harmful. I unsubscribed as quickly as I had subscribed when it was recommended—a podcast that omits harm to marginalized people on the internet isn’t for me, and I won’t be recommending it to others.

I am a boring millennial with no business getting famous on the Internet but I sure love this podcast. Amanda and Isabel are so infectious (in the good way) and I can’t get enough of them!

Craig here. I don’t come out from under my rock much (evidence: Apple Podcasts) but when I do, Isabel and Amanda always have new blorbos to show me. I appreciate how Isabel routinely brings up D

Love WIT so much -it is become a regular listen on my commute (yes I’m still commuting ahhh) . Interesting topics about tech thats not too techy and the best banter. Better than the majority of podcasts.

I literally don’t even use Apple Podcasts but you guys deserve to know that I think your podcast is good! It’s the highlight of my every-other-Wednesday. It’s good content and if you’re reading this review, you should listen to the podcast.

Just another Craig leaving another 5 star rating

Hi iz & mandy, I freaking love WIT. I’ve been following Iz on tumblr since we were both on the [REDACTED] Fic Writers server together (I eventually fell out of writing for [REDACTED] and regretfully left). It’s so nice to hear y’all talk about stuff I actually know and care about, it’s like hanging out with friends. Gotta love that parasocial relationship. Cool thanks. -Craig

IT'S TRUE! I love this podcast!! Isabel and Amanda are phenomenal hosts, and the topic of internet virality is really fascinating. Can't wait to hear more episodes!

Two friends having random and sometimes but not always insightful conversations with an audience that makes me feel like I’m part of it :’) The good parts of tumblr in podcast form! The hosts do not know what they are opening with a potential writing live-stream, forgetting that their audience is a good amount of non-neurotypicals who love that good good online body doubling coping mechanism

Honestly, this is a fantastic podcast! I usually listen to podcasts while doing laundry, but this had me sitting down to properly listen (and crack up) within minutes. I love the hosts’ banter!

So glad to add this podcast to my list of things to listen to when I’m feeling lonely and isolated! As close as I can get to existing in a room while smart and delightful friends chat.

Funny, conversational, an all-around good time with quirky niche histories to boot

Iz and amanda are so funny and smart! You’ll laugh a lot and also kind of think on things you never thought to think on. looking forward to more quality content!

two nichely internet famous people with podcastable voices producing #content in nice 30ish minute episodes? excellent. plz listen.

Hey this podcast is really fun and has great personalities you should check it out (also yeah I found this host through fan fiction what of it)

I’m so excited to listen to future episodes! I love internet culture and it’s so fun to dive into niches I wouldn’t find on my own. There’s great cohost chemistry!

I'm a huge lover of unique personalities and strange internet lore, and this podcast is the perfect blend of the two. The vibe is casual and inviting and every episode introduces me to people and parts of the internet I never knew existed. I look forward to every episode :>

Amanda and Isabel are geniuses before their time. A remarkable podcast. It really gets at the core of what it means to be a person on the internet — nay — what it means to be human. 🚀👽🛸

I love learning about weird/niche internet stuff. They talk about weird/niche internet stuff. We are all Craig from Craigslist, now.

I am very happy this is a thing and I’m also fan boying about a fanfic writer that I’ve followed for awhile being on a podcast which really tells you a lot about me in one sentence.Anyways, I hope the journey to internet fame is full of funny goofs and amazing opportunities.(sorry I’m not good at writing I’m only good at consuming the words with my eyes in an ungodly amount of time) -Mothman Craig

Absolutely loving the energy of this podcast! The combination of political and weird fandom memes clashing, plus insightful interviews with people who’ve gone viral is extremely compelling. Love a podcast hosted by smart, funny people and love to see where this goes next!

excited to watch this get off the ground, don’t let your memes be dreams 👍🏾

True