I’ve never left a review on a podcast before. But I couldn’t help myself, listen to the whole show from beginning to end the mystery. Punchers kept me endlessly entertained on my drives to and from work for quite a while. I definitely won’t be able to listen to any other live play RPG podcast after listening to these guys as my first one. I truly hope that eventually they will pick back up for another season. I need to find out what happens with the mystery punchers and cthiltler!!!!!!

My only complaint is I have a hard time enjoying other DND and RPG shows now…

Dumb, Dumb, & Dragons is one of the best fantasy series I’ve ever consumed. When I’m at my lowest it cheers me up. The show addresses many social issues, too. I could go on… You guys also create this podcast. I’m a cosmic horror junky, and I love your acting. But what the living f! You make fun of Diesel who is disabled. You even give him a voice of someone with language disability. And you laugh at how he talks. He sounds and acts like the young man I took care of when I was ten. If his parents took him out, people would seriously ask, “Well, what did you do to offend God so much?” implying he was a punishment. He finally got to go to church, because I was ruthless when other kids picked on him. I got thrown out of one Sunday school class permanently, because the teacher was so cruel, I let her have it. I cannot express how disappointed I am at your bigotry and laughing at disabled people. I don’t think I can listen to your other podcasts anymore. It’s too triggering. Im going to miss marathoning your stuff to get me happy after a crap day. You’re awesome. I’m not mad. Just really sad to see people as clever as you do something like that. Otherwise I LOVED this series.

Excellent production, character and story development, and interaction amongst the players. Highly recommend!

The best of the real play DD&D titles, by far. It’s like everything they did previously was just to setup this show and story. Incredibly interesting story and well done. It’s also incredibly funny to listen to Canadians use profanity.

Nice mix of camaraderie, humor, and spooky stuff.

This show is phenomenal. The cast charming (as always). The story is rich and compelling. All in all sold 10/10!

Just found, I was searching for a “Cthulhu” pod cast....I listen to a lot of Critical Role so thought this would be a good fit. Amazing voices and characters, Adrian is my favorite...super funny. Just started so am looking forward to binging, love Adrian eating the cake lol :) Thanks for the great material, keep it going. Cyrus Bayfield, CO

For what a terrible person he was in life, the best thing about Lovecraft was the resulting artists who have taken his works and made them better. The Mythos Mysteries have done just that. The beautiful and haunting storytelling combined with the varied and complex characters have brought me back to this podcast again and again. It mixes humor with serious and chilling moments so well. If you know the world of Call of Cthulhu, you’ll love how the pieces of the mythos are subtly placed for our Mystery Punchers to unravel the horrors. If you’re not or haven’t read any Lovecraft, be prepared to be swept up in an amazing story as they uncover the secrets long buried in Helmforth.

Every aspect of HPDumbcraft leads to some of the creepiest images I’ve ever mindscaped. Tom McGee is killer at painting spooky Cthulhu era imagery that builds & builds both environmental and character layers. I love every character in this game, but Sprinkles is the bestest. MUERR!